Skip to content
Home » Blog » Liberty Mutual Lawsuit and Jon Cross: A Case Study

Liberty Mutual Lawsuit and Jon Cross: A Case Study

Liberty Mutual Lawsuit and Jon Cross: A Case Study

Understanding the Liberty Mutual Lawsuit Involving State Rep. Jon Cross

In a scenario that highlights the complexities of insurance disputes, State Rep. Jon Cross and his wife find themselves embroiled in a lawsuit filed by Liberty Mutual Insurance. This case, stemming from a house fire insurance claim, unfolds against the backdrop of the Cross family’s significant home renovations and the intricacies of policy coverage.

The Genesis of the Dispute

The Liberty Mutual lawsuit was initiated following the unfortunate event of a fire that ravaged the Cross family’s home in Kenton, Ohio. The contention arises from Liberty Mutual’s claim that the Cross family undertook extensive upgrades and remodeling of their property without proper notification to the insurance company, as mandated by their policy agreement. These renovations, alleged to amount to $300,000, significantly increased the value of the house, which was originally purchased for $245,000 back in 2014.

Policy Stipulations and the Heart of the Dispute

According to Liberty Mutual, their policy requires homeowners to provide a 90-day notice for any updates that could potentially increase the home’s value by more than $5,000. The insurance giant contends that such a notification was not made by the Cross family, hence the lawsuit to potentially limit the payout to the policy limit, which caps at $634,390.40. This intricate case sheds light on the often-overlooked details of insurance policies and the importance of compliance with all terms and conditions.

Jon Cross’ Stance and the Ongoing Legal Battle

On his part, State Rep. Jon Cross, whose responsibilities span across District 83, including parts of Findlay, strongly refutes Liberty Mutual’s claims. Emphasizing that such insurance coverage disputes are common, he asserts that the lawsuit bears no relation to his public duties and vows to vigorously pursue justice in court. This stance underscores a resolve not only to seek Reimbursement for the fire damage but also to highlight the broader issue of insurance company practices concerning policyholders.

The Wider Implications

Beyond the specific details of the Liberty Mutual lawsuit and the house fire insurance claim, this case exemplifies the potential pitfalls homeowners might face when dealing with insurance claims. It serves as a cautionary tale about the critical need to thoroughly understand policy requirements and to diligently follow them to avoid disputes. Furthermore, it accentuates the necessity of open communication between insurance providers and policyholders, especially regarding significant changes to insured properties.


The legal tussle between Liberty Mutual Insurance and State Rep. Jon Cross, alongside his wife, regarding their house fire insurance claim, is a poignant reminder of the complexities embedded within insurance policies. As this case progresses, it not only unravels the specifics of a personal dispute but also casts a spotlight on the broader dynamics at play within the insurance industry. It underscores the importance of clear communication, understanding your policy’s fine print, and the inherent challenges of navigating insurance claims.

Share this post on social!
Sophia Johnson

Sophia Johnson

Sophia Johnson is a renowned real estate expert hailing from Monroe, NC, with over a decade of hands-on experience in the local market. Her extensive knowledge of Monroe's neighborhoods, schools, and market trends has made her an invaluable resource for both buyers and sellers. Known for her friendly demeanor and exceptional negotiation skills, Sophia consistently goes above and beyond to ensure her clients' success, whether they are first-time homebuyers or seasoned investors. Her dedication to providing personalized service and her profound understanding of the Monroe real estate landscape has solidified her reputation as one of the area's most trusted and effective agents.